| SEASON | TEAM |
| 2005 | Rangers |
| 2006 | Cardinals |
| 2007 | Yankees |
| 2008 | Diamondbacks |
| 2009 | Astros |
| 2010 | Athletics |
| 2011 | Blue Jays |
|
|
| SEASON | CHAMPIONSHIPS |
| 2005 | Rangers |
| 2006 | Cardinals |
| 2007 | Yankees |
| 2009 | Astros |
| 2010 | Athletics |
|
|
| SEASON | AWARD |
| 2005 | Rookie of the Year |
| 2005 | Play-off MVP |
| 2007 | Old Glove |
| 2007 | Play-off MVP |
| 2009 | MVP Season |
| 2009 | Play-off MVP |
| 2010 | Batting Champ |
| 2010 | Manager of the Year |
| 2010 | MVP Season |
| 2010 | Play-off Pitcher |
| 2011 | Old Glove |
|